Viviana Wrenn with her son at the Stebbins Avenue, Bronx, NYCHA development. She rarely has heat and the large windows let in a lot of cold air. Photo by Opheli Garcia Lawler
On Thanksgiving day, it was 22 degrees in New York City. It was the kind of cold that seeped through walls and drafted through windows. Viviana Wrenn was one of hundreds of New York City Housing Authority residents in the city who didn’t have heat. She and her son, who turned one-year-old just a few days before, huddled under blankets near her space heater to stay warm. After one month of living in the Stebbins Avenue Bronx NYCHA development, she said her apartment was heated less than 30 percent of the time.
Wrenn is not alone. Of the estimated 400,000 people living in the NYCHA housing developments, countless filed complaints over the Thanksgiving holidays about lack of heat, hot water and other essential services. The news reports closely about the lack of heat and hot water followed other recent public investigations into lead, mold, and vermin infestations that marred the agency’s reputation. NYCHA has launched several smaller programs to address certain developments’ most pressing problems, but with older buildings and costly system issues, even minor repairs are a challenge.
“I’ve had nothing but problems since I’ve moved in,” Wrenn said. “I’ve just got out of the family shelter system. I was living in the shelter system since I was pregnant. I was lucky enough to get an apartment with NYCHA.”
But the process of moving was riddled with issues. First her keys didn’t work. Then the apartment unit she moved into wasn’t clean and the door looked like it had been pried open by a crowbar. The intercom system for the entire housing complex didn’t work. Wrenn filed complaints repeatedly. They were marked as completed – but nothing changed. She contacted management. She stopped maintenance workers in the hallways. Nothing changed.
“I feel like they are constantly trying to pass the buck,” she said. Every system in place for Wrenn to address her issues failed her. Between working and taking care of her young son alone while her husband served his prison sentence, trying to make her home livable drains her remaining energy. “Whenever you put a ticket in for heat or hot water, they don’t contact you. They don’t have maintenance come and check what could possibly be wrong.”
“It’s very frustrating. I give my son a warm bath, and as soon as I take him out of his bath, he’s shivering. In his towel. Which is wrong.”
Caridad Nova also lives in NYCHA housing. She lives in the South Jamaica projects in Queens. Her heat works and her windows don’t let in the cold air, but her ceiling lets in the rain. She’s lived in NYCHA housing almost her whole life with the exception of two and a half years she spent living in the family shelter system. Nova lives with her daughter, who is only three years old.
“Every time I report that I have a problem in my apartment, they don’t come on the day when I ask them,” Nova said. “Like right now, I have a leak in my living room, right? And everytime it rains, it’s like it’s raining in my house. I reported it before, and they never came. So I reported it again.”
Nova said that she’s had the leak in her ceiling for three weeks. Every storm brings cold, wet weather into her apartment. She and her daughter developed asthma while they were living in the family shelter system, and the damp air doesn’t help. Previous studies have found links between people who live in shelters and high rates of asthma.
“I haven’t gotten any of my furniture yet because I’m waiting for them to fix what they need to fix,” Nova said. “They need to renew NYCHA, NYCHA buildings, they need to do something. Because this is crazy. Everything is getting worse by the day.”
The conditions Wrenn and Nova described have caused a public crisis. Lynne Patton, who oversees New York and New Jersey’s Division of the Federal Housing and Urban Development agency expressed extreme dismay on Twitter following the circulation of a video of a NYCHA resident recorded her ceiling leaking. “Dear Migrant Caravan: We know the majority of you seek asylum for a better life in America,” Patton wrote, to people fleeing “abject poverty” in their home countries. “Well, with all due respect, don’t come to NYC.”
While Patton’s comments were not widely accepted by many New York City politicians – NYC Council Speaker Corey Johnson called the remarks a “publicity stunt” – those living under the conditions of NYCHA housing aren’t batting an eye at dramatic comparisons. On Dec. 3, the water at the Patterson Houses, another development managed by NYCHA that is also in the Bronx, lost all water. Tenants were forced to line up on the block in cold temperatures in order to get water from fire hydrants.
“Staff have been working on repairing the house pumps and are in the process of setting up temporary pumps now,” NYCHA officials said in a statement to the press about the Patterson water outages. “This is yet another example of the problems we face given our aging infrastructure, but we must do better providing basic services despite these challenges.”
New York City Council member Rafael Salamanca represents the 17th District and 15,000 NYCHA residents. His district has the third largest population of NYCHA tenants. His office has made a point of actively showing up at NYCHA developments when issues facing residents go unaddressed. He is aware that NYCHA will sometimes only address an issue after they’ve been publicly called out.
“From broken elevators to huge holes in the walls to leaking roofs, many of the 15,520 NYCHA residents I represent live under terrible conditions, and it’s an utter disgrace,” said Council Member Rafael Salamanca Jr. “NYCHA is broken. Years of mismanagement and dwindling federal investment has left hundreds of thousands of NYCHA residents in unlivable apartments. NYCHA is NYC’s biggest landlord and they should be able to address the basic requirements demanded of any landlord. My office has been working hard to remedy issues constituents face and hold NYCHA accountable.”
Throughout an endless number of issues, NYCHA’s response – if there is one – has targeted specific and immediate issues. Following the multiple news reports this year about unfulfilled maintenance requests (like Viviana’s), NYCHA announced a program in July 2018 to fulfill 50,000 requests through 2019. The program is called NYCHA Cares.
“NYCHA Cares is the latest demonstration of the Authority’s renewed commitment to improving our residents’ quality of life both today and tomorrow,” said NYCHA General Manager Vito Mustaciuolo in a statement to the press. “We are focused every day on making sure our residents know that we are not only listening to their needs but also working proactively to deliver tangible results.”
The maintenance repairs happened in “blitzes.” Hundreds of work orders would be filled in over a single Saturday. On Dec. 8 five different developments were repaired – none of those developments were Caridad Nova’s or Viviana Wrenn’s. Posts on NYCHA’s Twitter account showed sinks being repaired, door knockers being fixed and plumbing issues being addressed.
“Saturday maintenance work order blitz is kicking off at 5 [sic] sites across the City” the agency wrote on Twitter. “If you’re a Baruch, Patterson, Kingsborough, Ravenswood or West Brighton resident, management offices are open for recerts and other assistance until 4:30 today.”
But even as work orders are being addressed, residents are still having to endure daunting living situations in the interim. Viviana Wrenn was told that she would have to wait until Dec. 21 until her broken fridge (which was broken when she moved in) was fixed. NYCHA previously filed that her work order was fixed– but Wrenn still tapes her fridge shut with duct tape.
While work orders can be filled and issues like clogged toilets and broken fridges can be fixed, if maintenance workers do show up – citywide issues with aging infrastructure and lack of sufficient funding leave residents like Caridad Nova and Viviana Wrenn feeling like they’ve abandoned by their local government. They are systemic issues that cannot be repaired in a maintenance “blitz.” As the temperatures continue to drop, residents without heat and hot water might have to live through more cold holidays – and hope that the rain and snow stays out of their living rooms.
“If you wouldn’t live in our buildings in these conditions,” Wrenn said. “Why would you make us live in these buildings in these conditions?”
My mother who is 78 years old was forced to move out of Grandparents building at 951prospect ave bronx, ny.My mother Ann Ford,was told she had to take an apt at3204 Park ave
However, she wasn’t made aware that the apt wasn’t livable.The kitchen pipes were broken,water flooding out into the hallway.The promised to come but no one shows up. HELP