Special Report

Shutdown: The Coronavirus

Lawmakers, Legal Experts Clash Over Much Needed Business Interruption Insurance Coverage for Small Businesses

Photo courtesy of Andy Husbands. Andy Husbands, the owner of The Smoke Shop in Boston, has seen his business turned upside down by COVID-19.

On March 11, as COVID-19 spread across the world, Italy closed all shops and restaurants nationwide.  The next day, as the United States reported more than 1,000 cases, a group of chefs discussed the widening pandemic over dinner in a sprawling Romanesque mansion on New Orleans’ historic St. Charles Avenue.

The elegant dinner party was hosted by John Houghtaling, a partner at Gauthier, Murphy and Houghtaling, who had built a name for himself by representing property owners against insurers following Hurricane Katrina and Superstorm Sandy, securing hundreds of millions of dollars for the victims of those crises.

That afternoon, a Texas-based attorney passed along a memo to Houghtaling describing how some insurance companies planned to reject claims filed by restaurants and other businesses that would be forced to close to stop the spread of the virus. When the chefs arrived, he had to break the bad news. While many of them had insurance policies designed to protect them from unexpected interruptions in their operations,   they shouldn’t expect to see a payout.

The memo outraged Houghtaling, who realized that thousands of small business owners, particularly restaurant owners, would be hit hard by the pandemic and see no relief from insurers. He decided right then that he would take action, and the party quickly became a strategy session.

“Every day I get calls about the restaurant industry failing, so we need a quick solution,”  Houghtaling said.

“They need it,’’ he said of the insurance payouts.  “It’s critical. If they do not get it, they will fail.”

On March 17, Houghtaling filed a lawsuit on behalf of New Orleans Restaurant Oceana Grill against its insurer, demanding payment of the restaurant’s business interruption insurance during the coronavirus pandemic, the first suit of its kind in the nation. The lawsuit highlights a legal strategy embraced by lawyers and restaurant owners hoping to salvage an industry that is reeling from the effects of coronavirus shutdowns.

About 30 percent of small businesses hold business interruption insurance policies, but many have learned that their insurer will not cover shutdowns caused by the coronavirus pandemic. Many business interruption policies have explicit virus exclusions, clauses that bar business interruption coverage caused by viruses, a common addition since the mid-2000s.

In other cases, business owners have learned that they do not technically qualify for coverage without physical damage to their property. Because Oceana Grill does not have a virus exclusion, Houghtaling’s lawsuit argues that the infectious virus does qualify as physical loss.

A handful of similar lawsuits have cropped up across the country, and eight state governments have proposed bills that would force insurers to pay. Notably, the Chikasee and Choctaw nations have filed suits against their insurers, and Houghtaling himself filed another suit on behalf of celebrity chef Thomas Keller.

But while the stakes are high for attorneys like Houghtaling, small business owners are fighting for their lives against a ticking clock.

Twenty eight states have mandated that restaurants suspend dine-in services, and many more are impacted by shelter in place orders. By the end of March, the National Restaurant Association estimated that roughly 30,000 of the more than 1 million restaurants in the U.S. had to close permanently as a result, and projected another 110,000 more would shutter in April.

Many restaurant owners fear that legal settlements and new legislation may come too late. Many are already running out of cash and nearly out of time, barely holding on financially as these legal and political squabbles play out around them.

“I’ve been through 9/11, 2008, 10-foot snowstorms, a lot of this stuff,” said Andy Husbands, a Boston restaurateur who has been told that his insurer is unlikely to pay out his business interruption insurance policy.

“We knew we would get past it, we just had to work hard,’’ Husbands said of previous crises. “We knew the snow would melt. We don’t know what the future holds now.”

The insurance industry argues that its reserves, about $820 billion, cannot cover all of the business interruption claims arising as a result of the pandemic. Many insurers are calling for more government relief.

“There are certain issues that just cannot be 100 percent supported by the insurance industry,” said Tyler Bartosh, Vice President of Sales at Top o’ Michigan Insurance Solutions.

Bartosh suggested the creation of a partnership in which the federal government would share risk with the insurers. Without such collaboration, he warned, the insurance industry could be overwhelmed by the business interruption claims.

“I definitely think there’s a position for the industry and federal government to work together to figure out how we can protect against any future pandemic,”he said.

In the meantime, the lawsuits filed by Houghtaling and others are winding their way through the courts. For the insurance industry, this boils down to simple contract law and interpretation.

Generally speaking, for an interruption policy to kick in, some form of physical damage or the threat of it must be the cause of the business shutdown. Despite the fact that the coronavirus can contaminate surfaces and create unsafe environments, it may not qualify as physical damage.

“The key issues will be whether coronavirus constitutes physical loss or damage under the policy, because those are the triggering words,” said Steven Badger, a Texas-based attorney who represents a number of insurers, and shared the memo with Houghtaling that night in March.

Recognizing the importance of the restaurant industry, and how quickly it could collapse, Houghtaling began working quickly to turn up the heat on insurers and get relief to restaurants.

What followed was a flurry of legal and political actions. Houghtaling and seven celebrity chefs founded the Business Interruption Group, a non-profit organization designed to pressure insurers and get information to the public and Washington. Although the results remain to be seen, Houghtaling, whose firm played a leading role in the $246 billion class action suit against tobacco companies in 1998, said that this legal fight would “dwarf tobacco in terms of its significance.”

“We are demanding the insurance industry pay the policies they owe,” Houghtaling said. “Certain [business interruption insurance] policies have exclusions for viruses, but many do not. They need to pay the ones that do not.”

Houghtaling dismissed concerns raised by insurers who argue that their reserves can’t cover all of the payouts sought by shuttered businesses.

“My argument is, when the Titanic was sinking, and they didn’t have enough lifeboats for everyone, the captain didn’t say ‘well, we don’t have enough so we aren’t going to lower any,’ he lowered the ones that he had,” Houghtaling said. “We need to lower the lifeboats that we have and that we paid for, and then we need a solution to save the rest.”

James Duffy is an NYU undergraduate journalism student in Prof. Rachel Swarns’ Advanced Reporting: Law & Order


Other Stories in Special Report: Shutdown: The Coronavirus

During pandemic, Rio de Janeiro residents fear police

Marina Guimaraes May 27, 2020

Recovering from drugs during a pandemic

Kyla Milberger May 26, 2020

  Covid-19 takes away the communal joy at Eid-al-Fitr celebration

Narkwor Kwablaa May 25, 2020

Beloved old school game sees boom in numbers during coronavirus quarantine

Michael Yang May 15, 2020

Coronavirus leaves the fate of some beloved New York events uncertain

Emily Glass May 15, 2020

South Africa’s lockdown exposes inequalities

Kathleen Taylor May 14, 2020

Churchgoers find spiritual growth through virtual services 

Harrison Tsui May 14, 2020

” I’m working with COVID patients tonight”

Margaret Guzman May 14, 2020

Singles connect on Tinder to fight quarantine blues 

Yaroslava Bondar May 14, 2020

Jewish traditions during a pandemic

Sydney Fishman May 13, 2020

The Bible and Coronavirus

Jonathan Sarabia May 13, 2020

Doctor uses social media to give advice and hope

Sope Aluko May 12, 2020

First Sandy, Now COVID: Lower East Side Activists Grapple With Construction for Climate Project

Izzie Ramirez May 12, 2020

Dating during a pandemic

Bessie Liu May 12, 2020

The last reponders

Shiyu Xu May 11, 2020

When the pandemic hits a shelter for abused boys 

Amanda Perez Pintado May 11, 2020

Portugal contains the coronavirus despite Spain’s woes

Catarina Lamelas Moura May 11, 2020

Warm weather brings crowds to Prospect Park

Bessie Liu May 11, 2020

New York coronavirus numbers continue to fall

Jonathan Sarabia May 10, 2020

Living through the pandemic while a loved one is behind bars

Amanda Perez Pintado May 10, 2020

Pandemic ends all high school senior year traditions

Jonathan Sarabia May 10, 2020

Coronavirus might have caused the death of many children who were misdiagnosed 

Ximena Del Cerro May 9, 2020

Farmers destroy staggering amounts of food even as food lines grow

Karen Camela Watson May 9, 2020

Coronavirus pandemic threatens border towns in Mexico

Sydney Fishman and Ximena Del Cerro May 9, 2020

Pence’s press secretary tests positive for Covid-19

Shiyu Xu May 8, 2020

During pandemic NYC tenants in limbo

John DiLillo May 8, 2020

Llamas could be coronavirus heroes

Catarina Lamelas Moura May 8, 2020

Rent relief in NY, JetBlue’s flyover and Trump’s valet tests positive for coronavirus in today’s news

Amanda Perez Pintado May 7, 2020

Coronavirus tears through the Navajo Nation 

Amanda Perez Pintado May 7, 2020

In Singapore, spaces close, but restaurants open

Yifan Yu May 6, 2020

Press secretary calls Fauci testifying before congress “publicity stunt”

Kathleen Taylor May 6, 2020

Harry Potter and the Magical Malady of the Movies

Ahad Sanwari May 6, 2020

Trump speaks to human loss, Cuomo lashes out at President’s comments

Catarina Lamelas Moura May 5, 2020

PPE in the city

Narkwor Kwabla May 5, 2020

Boring Politics is Good Politics – Especially in a Pandemic

Serafina Smith May 5, 2020

Stuck: Life under quarantine in Rio de Janeiro

Marina Guimaraes May 5, 2020

New York’s Emptiness

Maria Abreu May 5, 2020

In an Airbnb Room During Lockdown in Jamaica, Queens

Dayo Paul May 4, 2020

What Temporary Means: Portraits of family at home

Guillermo Manning May 4, 2020

Stockholm Stays Open

Tatiana Kireeva May 4, 2020

NYC now producing its own coronavirus test kits

Maureen Mullarkey May 3, 2020

Miss you, mom: Spending Ramadan together through a screen

Maznah Shehzad May 3, 2020

Life in front of a screen

Patricio Zenklussen May 3, 2020

Coronavirus and the Shincheonji

Bessie Liu May 3, 2020

It’s The Little Things

Sope Aluko May 3, 2020

Days In, Days Out: A doctor’s life during Covid-19

Elsa Benamouzig May 2, 2020

Contactless: Food Delivery amid COVID-19

Keighton Li May 2, 2020

Hasidic South Williamsburg Resists the New Reality

Leo Schwartz May 2, 2020

Solace in Suburbia

Susanne Schweitzer May 2, 2020

Puerto Rico rocked by 5.4 magnitude earthquake

Amanda Perez Pintado May 2, 2020