Special Report

Shutdown: The Coronavirus

Portugal contains the coronavirus despite Spain’s woes

Portugal has been able to contain the coronavirus outbreak. Photo by @sashapritchard via Twenty20

Portugal and Spain share an open border at the western most point of Europe. Yet they have fared quite differently in the face of the coronavirus pandemic. While Spain’s population is close to five times bigger than Portugal’s, the number of deaths from COVID-19 is over 20 times as high.

Spain declared a state of emergency on March 14, only four days before Portugal followed suit. And while they ramped up containment measures in a similar timeline, their situation was already disparate: Portugal had only three deaths due to COVID-19, and Spain had 84.

In other words, Portugal responded to the coronavirus before the situation got out of control. The country benefited from a later arrival of the coronavirus, with an estimated lag of between a week and a half to two weeks, according Filipe Froes, lung specialist and advisor to the country’s department of health.

“These days of preparation were precious,” he said.

They allowed Portugal to assemble a response strategy for the national healthcare system, before it could be overwhelmed with coronavirus cases. In fact, the country never even reached a state where hospitals became overwhelmed with the number of patients.

“We could have had these days of advance and not have done anything,” Froes said. “We had the merit of knowing how to utilize the days of advance that the pandemic gave us.”

Portugal established a primary health care network, which sorted through cases, only allowing the most serious ones to go to hospitals, effectively controlling the inflow of patients and allowing hospitals to manage them with ease.

Froes gave the following example: if 1,000 people are sick, maybe 800 will have slight symptoms and 200 will need to be admitted, and of those maybe 50 will need to go to the intensive care unit. But in order to get to those 50, the hospital would still need to go through 1,000 patients. 

“If you don’t see 1,000 and see, for example, around 300, you have a much better capacity of identifying the 50 that are going to intensive care,” Froes said. “That’s what we did.”

The strategy itself is not groundbreaking, he stressed — more importantly, the timeframe in which it was implemented was key. Both countries took action “practically on the same day”, around mid-March, but the case count at that point was much lower in Portugal, which only saw its first confirmed case on March 2.

It also allowed for time for hospitals to increase their intensive care unit capacity.

“In my hospital [Hospital Pulido Valente, to which he is Head of Intensive Care Unit], we went from 20 to 60 or 80 beds, which at the time aren’t even fully occupied,” he said.

Ricardo Mexia, a public health doctor at the Department of Epidemiology of the National Association of Public Health Doctors, said that Portugal wasn’t particularly well prepared to take on this pandemic.

“We had the fortune of being affected later. We ended up having the opportunity of buying some time, so that everything could work and measures were put in place earlier,” he said. “This avoided an exponential growth, it avoided a situation in which our national healthcare system would have to respond beyond its capacity, like it happened in Spain.”

It’s also relevant to look at the way the outbreaks started in both countries, he said. While Madrid has a much more complicated situation than the rest of Spain, we can also see that the southern region of Alentejo, in Portugal, with its low population density, has a much lower number of cases.

The virus hit both countries in very distinct ways.

“Both in Italy and in Spain, the beginning of the [pandemic] activity was very explosive,” Froes said. “It happened in multiple outbreaks simultaneously, in various places.”

In Spain, early on, the virus hit a more susceptible part of the population, he said.

“When an outbreak involves a hospital or a nursing home you have the conditions for a faster dissemination in a very fragile population, that is then going to need a lot of health care,” he said. 

Meanwhile, in Portugal, the initial outbreak had been traced back to a group of businessmen that had traveled back from a trade fair in Milan.

“It is a younger age group and a group that is not as tied to chronic illnesses,” he said. “Therefore, healthier people. And those people don’t attend health institutions and most likely didn’t go to nursing homes.”

All and all, experts agree, that the contrast between Portugal and Spain is most likely due to timing, combined with the government’s capacity to make use of that time and implementing the measures that needed to be put in place. In the future, more information will fill in some of the blanks, and allow them to draw more permanent conclusions.

Froes also stressed the way the Portuguese responded.

“I think that up until now the population in general was compliant and showed proof of great civism,” he said.

Some other factors have been pinpointed as potential variables. The rate of BCG vaccination, for example, is higher in Portugal than it is in Spain. And some studies have suggested (while not confirmed) that this vaccine — which protects against tuberculosis — might also have a protective effect towards complications developed from COVID-19.

Others have also pointed out how in Portugal different political parties have put aside their differences and banded together in the fight against COVID-19. The leader of the biggest opposition party (PSD) made his support clear when the state of emergency was declared, speaking in front of parliament.

“It’s important that the country knows that [our party] PSD supports the government in this battle,” he said. “Mr. Prime Minister, count on the collaboration of PDS.  With everything we can, we will help. I wish you courage, nerves of steel and a lot of luck. Because your luck is our luck.”

Meanwhile, the Spanish government has been hindered by political fighting with the right wing opposition parties. Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez has not been able to count on the support of other political leaders, in a country characterized by a starkly polarized political field and disunion among its people.

As of early May, the number of confirmed cases in Spain reached over 224,000, while Portugal has over 27,000. Both countries are now taking their first steps to reopen the economy.



Other Stories in Special Report: Shutdown: The Coronavirus

During pandemic, Rio de Janeiro residents fear police

Marina Guimaraes May 27, 2020

Recovering from drugs during a pandemic

Kyla Milberger May 26, 2020

  Covid-19 takes away the communal joy at Eid-al-Fitr celebration

Narkwor Kwablaa May 25, 2020

Beloved old school game sees boom in numbers during coronavirus quarantine

Michael Yang May 15, 2020

Coronavirus leaves the fate of some beloved New York events uncertain

Emily Glass May 15, 2020

South Africa’s lockdown exposes inequalities

Kathleen Taylor May 14, 2020

Churchgoers find spiritual growth through virtual services 

Harrison Tsui May 14, 2020

” I’m working with COVID patients tonight”

Margaret Guzman May 14, 2020

Singles connect on Tinder to fight quarantine blues 

Yaroslava Bondar May 14, 2020

Jewish traditions during a pandemic

Sydney Fishman May 13, 2020

The Bible and Coronavirus

Jonathan Sarabia May 13, 2020

Doctor uses social media to give advice and hope

Sope Aluko May 12, 2020

First Sandy, Now COVID: Lower East Side Activists Grapple With Construction for Climate Project

Izzie Ramirez May 12, 2020

Dating during a pandemic

Bessie Liu May 12, 2020

The last reponders

Shiyu Xu May 11, 2020

When the pandemic hits a shelter for abused boys 

Amanda Perez Pintado May 11, 2020

Warm weather brings crowds to Prospect Park

Bessie Liu May 11, 2020

New York coronavirus numbers continue to fall

Jonathan Sarabia May 10, 2020

Living through the pandemic while a loved one is behind bars

Amanda Perez Pintado May 10, 2020

Pandemic ends all high school senior year traditions

Jonathan Sarabia May 10, 2020

Coronavirus might have caused the death of many children who were misdiagnosed 

Ximena Del Cerro May 9, 2020

Farmers destroy staggering amounts of food even as food lines grow

Karen Camela Watson May 9, 2020

Coronavirus pandemic threatens border towns in Mexico

Sydney Fishman and Ximena Del Cerro May 9, 2020

Pence’s press secretary tests positive for Covid-19

Shiyu Xu May 8, 2020

During pandemic NYC tenants in limbo

John DiLillo May 8, 2020

Llamas could be coronavirus heroes

Catarina Lamelas Moura May 8, 2020

Lawmakers, Legal Experts Clash Over Much Needed Business Interruption Insurance Coverage for Small Businesses

James Duffy May 8, 2020

Rent relief in NY, JetBlue’s flyover and Trump’s valet tests positive for coronavirus in today’s news

Amanda Perez Pintado May 7, 2020

Coronavirus tears through the Navajo Nation 

Amanda Perez Pintado May 7, 2020

In Singapore, spaces close, but restaurants open

Yifan Yu May 6, 2020

Press secretary calls Fauci testifying before congress “publicity stunt”

Kathleen Taylor May 6, 2020

Harry Potter and the Magical Malady of the Movies

Ahad Sanwari May 6, 2020

Trump speaks to human loss, Cuomo lashes out at President’s comments

Catarina Lamelas Moura May 5, 2020

PPE in the city

Narkwor Kwabla May 5, 2020

Boring Politics is Good Politics – Especially in a Pandemic

Serafina Smith May 5, 2020

Stuck: Life under quarantine in Rio de Janeiro

Marina Guimaraes May 5, 2020

New York’s Emptiness

Maria Abreu May 5, 2020

In an Airbnb Room During Lockdown in Jamaica, Queens

Dayo Paul May 4, 2020

What Temporary Means: Portraits of family at home

Guillermo Manning May 4, 2020

Stockholm Stays Open

Tatiana Kireeva May 4, 2020

NYC now producing its own coronavirus test kits

Maureen Mullarkey May 3, 2020

Miss you, mom: Spending Ramadan together through a screen

Maznah Shehzad May 3, 2020

Life in front of a screen

Patricio Zenklussen May 3, 2020

Coronavirus and the Shincheonji

Bessie Liu May 3, 2020

It’s The Little Things

Sope Aluko May 3, 2020

Days In, Days Out: A doctor’s life during Covid-19

Elsa Benamouzig May 2, 2020

Contactless: Food Delivery amid COVID-19

Keighton Li May 2, 2020

Hasidic South Williamsburg Resists the New Reality

Leo Schwartz May 2, 2020

Solace in Suburbia

Susanne Schweitzer May 2, 2020

Puerto Rico rocked by 5.4 magnitude earthquake

Amanda Perez Pintado May 2, 2020