Special Report

Reporting Black America

Elizabeth Wellington on “Choosing Blackness”

Philadelphia Inquirer columnist, Elizabeth Wellington, zooms into NYU Journalism’s Reporting Black America class to discuss the newspaper’s project “Wildest Dreams” which explores the joys of Black Philadelphia.

For 5-year-old Elizabeth Wellington, her mother’s fair skin was an obvious sign that she was a white woman. Even though she often rocked Pam Grier-esque, mega Afro or blonde-streaked press and curl hairstyles, she was still white in Wellington’s eyes. While their complexions were worlds apart, there was still no doubt in her mind that Margaret Wellington was her biological mother.

Wellington’s racial reckoning can be traced back to a moment in time when she had likened a white actress on TV to her mother, expressing that they were both white women. At that moment, her mother, the older Wellington, gently took her hands and explained that although her skin tone was very light, she was a Black woman. In her recently-published article “Choosing Blackness, a piece in an anthology series for The Philadelphia Inquirer’s “Wildest Dreams” project, Wellington details the incident, describing it as a moment where her 5-year-old self was initially confused at the realization, but also, eventually relieved. 

Now sitting in on a Zoom call with Journalism students from New York University where she is being interviewed, Wellington, an NYU Alumni herself and a reporter at The Philadelphia Inquirer, answered questions about race in America, Black identity, and her journey as a Black female reporter. It has been one week since her article was published as part of a landmark series on Black identity, and the NYU class she is speaking at is called Reporting Black America. 

Behind her, attached to an austere gray-colored wall, is a wide, black picture frame with clippings of two newspaper articles inside it. Surrounded by the picture frame are various paintings, greeting cards, handmade drawings, and a few pieces of 8.4 x 11 paper stapled together. 

In the article, Wellington writes that the startling realization of her mother’s Blackness shaped how she would grow up to define herself as a Black woman in America, and inspired her to go on a search to gather information about her family’s background.

“At the end of the day, my mother is a Black woman, and she taught me how to be a Black woman, and I am happy that she made that choice,” she said.

In the process of digging into her past, Wellington discovered that her maternal grandfather, James L. Wilkins, who she often affectionately called Daddy Wilkie, grew up in an era where many Black people who looked white, made the unequivocal decision to absolve themselves of their Blackness and identify as white because of the influence of the Jim Crow racial caste system. In “Choosing Blackness”, Wellington aptly describes her grandfather as “someone who had porcelain skin and eyes that alternated between blue and green — depending on the color tie he was wearing.”

 Of course, tracing her ancestry and heritage meant that Wellington would uncover the bitter traces of slavery and the stamp that it left on her side of the family for generations.

“In the 1400s when Black people originally came to this country as slaves, some of the white men would sleep with the Black slaves, eventually making them pregnant, and while the Europeans originally said that children of born into that system would assume the identity of their fathers, in reality, it was economically better for the children to remain slaves, and identify as Black and that is what happened,” she said

During the Zoom call, Wellington candidly spoke about her experiences as a Black reporter.  She details her start in journalism by sharing that she had initially gotten her foot in the door after she applied to an internship through the National Association of Black Journalists (NABJ), and got in. Her career progressed from there.

When Bianca Brutus, an NYU senior at the College of Arts and Sciences, asked if she had ever experienced colorism, she paused shortly, before agreeing that she had.

“I grew up in New York in the 80s and 90s, and some of my earliest memories, are of people telling me that I did not look like my mother, but instead, they would say that my sister looked more like my mother because she was a couple of shades lighter than I was, even though we had the same nose and eyes,” she said.

Although she acknowledged that colorism was rampant within the Black community, she  expressed that it was a long-standing derivative of racism that had been foisted on Black people right from the days of slavery.

“I have been privileged to see a change,” she said of colorism. “I was born in 1973, and I shouldn’t even say that out loud, but the 70s, 80s and early 90s were characterized by people defining themselves as Black, no matter what percentage of Blackness they had in them, and I think that was a product of culture and society.”

While she acknowledges the damage that racism caused in the Black community, Wellington said that the concept of racial classification was not created by Black people, but by the environment that they found themselves in.

“Race is a construct, and from what we know,” she said. “Black people did not create this construct, but it affected them and eventually produced colorism. People are different, and while there are some biological differences like the presence of melanin and different bone structures, how we work as humans is pretty much the same.”

According to Wellington, the years following the Civil Rights movement did a lot to soften the impact of colorism, but there is still a gray area that exists when discussing Black culture, and what part of it white people get interconnected in, especially through the performing arts.

“You have someone like Rachel Dolezal who is a white woman but chose to identify as Black, and the issue is that she got to assume that identity without truly experiencing the pitfalls of it, and then you have Teena Marie, who was often confused for a Black woman, but the difference was that she was very clear about her whiteness,” she said.

In a candid moment, Wellington acknowledged that Black culture had left an indelible mark on other cultures, and its impact was especially eminent in American white spaces.

“White people have always been a part of the culture,” she said.,“You have people like the Beastie Boys, and Eminem who are rappers, and have embraced a part of the culture, but the problem arises when some white people use elements of the culture without acknowledging its Black history.” 

The students wanted to know what was Wellington’s wildest dream.

“My real wildest dream is to sit my behind at home, work on my novel, and drink wine all damn day,” she said  with a light flip of her dreadlocks.




Other Stories in Special Report: Reporting Black America

Sonic Serenity: A review of the music that carried Black folks through 2021

Vanessa Handy December 16, 2021

Despite uptick in diversity numbers, Black students say inclusive spaces are rare

Sanya Khurana December 16, 2021

African students says mispronouncing their names is a form of racism

Eniola Oshiafi December 16, 2021

Young adult Black immigrants forge new lives and battle racial inequalities

Shawn Kang December 13, 2021

The Chaotic Birth of a Coffee Shop

Austin Barron December 12, 2021

Afrobeat musicians make strides

Kirill Bykanov December 11, 2021

Black photographer’s work reveals the power and beauty of Blackness

Austin Barron November 28, 2021

For young Indo-Caribbean adults, culture is complex and a source of pride

Vanessa Handy November 28, 2021

Challenges persist for Black women who seek degrees in STEM

George Papazov November 27, 2021

Black bookstore owner say last year’s surging sales was part of anti-racism movement

Eniola Oshiafi November 27, 2021

Choosing natural hair for children

Sanya Khurana November 26, 2021

A Black artist refuses labels

Monique Ezeh November 26, 2021

Some Black Parents are Choosing Afrocentric Preschools for their Children

Sanya Khurana November 12, 2021

The quest to diversify NYC’s specialized high schools 

Vanessa Handy November 11, 2021

Healthcare disparities hurts African immigrants

Shawn Kang November 8, 2021

African Women Migrating to Escape Oppression

Eniola Oshiafi November 8, 2021

Black New Yorkers Want Manhattan’s First Black District Attorney To Be ‘Tough’

Austin Barron November 3, 2021

The only woman of color in Nashua’s city council is reelected

Kirill Bykanov November 3, 2021

Black doulas are challenging rampant healthcare disparity

Sughnen Yongo-Okochi October 26, 2021

Interest in African art is growing

George Papazov October 15, 2021

Black queer community often at odds with police

Monique Ezeh October 14, 2021

Celebrating the Everyday Normalcy in Black Life

Austin Barron October 10, 2021

Liberation through imagination

Vanessa Handy October 10, 2021

Penfield’s Black Supermoms Make Sure School Kids know Black Kids Matter

Sanya Khurana October 8, 2021