Special Report

Election 2012

Third party candidates: A long shot worth taking?

From right to left: Richard Gottfried, Karen Young, Ron Moore, Ben Becker, Scott Spiegel. Surrogates for presidential candidates in the third party debate held at Hudson Guild community center on October 24, 2012. Photo by Joanna Marshall.

When voters head to the polls on Tuesday, they will discover a few people on the ballot who are not exactly household names, such as Jill Stein or Peta Lindsay. Who are they and how do you not know about them if they are running for president of the United States?

Every election year, third party candidates run even though their chances of winning are next to impossible. The presidential candidates who will appear on the New York state ballot this year are: Jill Stein of the Green Party, Gary Johnson of the Libertarian Party, Peta Lindsay of the Party for Socialism and Liberation and Virgil Goode of the Constitution Party.

In stark contrast to the huge crowds that have greeted Barack Obama and Mitt Romney or surrogate speakers such as Bill Clinton in the final weeks of the campaign, only thirty people showed up at the Hudson Guild community center in Chelsea for the third party surrogates debate on October 24th. The crowd was predominately white and over 60-years-old with a smattering of young people from a mix of racial backgrounds. Six place cards were laid out on a folding table at the front of the room, but only five surrogates were seated. (Apparently the Constitution Party didn’t RSVP for the event.)

None of the surrogate speakers appeared to be well-known either. Ron Moore, membership director and former chairman of the Manhattan Libertarians, represented the Gary Johnson campaign. Karen Young, a staff member of the Writers Guild of America, spoke on behalf of Jill Stein and the Green Party. Ben Becker, a U.S. history Ph.D. candidate at CUNY and Occupy Wall Street activist, debated for Peta Lindsay, the 28-year-old Party for Socialism and Liberation candidate.

To ensure a robust debate, Democrat and Republican representatives were invited as well. Richard Gottfried, State Assemblyman for District 75, spoke on behalf of the Democrats. Scott Spiegel, a member of the Log Cabin Republicans, defended the Romney-Ryan ticket.

The first speaker, State Assemblyman Gottfried, unintentionally thrust the American political party duopoly into the forefront of the debate, saying, “This election is about two competing visions of what government and this country ought to be about.” Third parties disagree that there should be only two visions of the country’s future. Libertarian Moore rebutted that position by saying, “I don’t think there are just two visions. I see about thirty people in this room and I think there are thirty visions.”

Occupy Wall street activist Becker, who looks like Clark Kent with tousled black hair and a square jaw, spiritedly replied with his campaign’s “Seize the Banks” slogan. He  argued that  although there may be great philosophical differences between the Republican and Democratic visions, “in practice when it comes to the two parties’ economic programs, they’ve been shown to be quite similar and both ultimately at the service of Wall Street.”

Ralph Nader’s Green Party presidential campaign in 2000 was the most influential third party campaign of the last twenty years. Nader’s success in the swing state of Florida coincided with a minute margin of votes between Republican George W. Bush and Democrat Al Gore. Since Bush was declared the winner of Florida based on only a few hundred highly contested votes, many Democrats in their frustration at the narrow loss of the presidency blamed Nader for siphoning potentially Democratic voters from Gore’s ticket.

Karen Young, the Green Party representative, skirted mentioning Nader explicitly, but did touch on this controversy in more general terms. “The worst thing that could happen if you and all your friends and family were to vote for Jill Stein is that Obama might win New York State by a few less percentage points than he otherwise would,” said Young. “The latest poll showed that Obama was leading New York with 62 percent of the vote. If Jill even got 10 percent of that—which is unlikely—Obama would still win by 20 points.” In the nine swing states, every single vote is likely to matter, but in reliably Democratic states such as New York or Massachusetts or in historically safe GOP states such as Texas and South Carolina, many people can indeed feel free to vote for third party candidates without seriously endangering a Republican or Democratic candidate that they might ultimately prefer to win.

The third party candidates can play a role by highlighting important issues. As Young put it, “The point is that by having a political party and running candidates we can have our progressive ideas and alternative solutions on the table.” If a third party candidate gains serious support from voters, the primary candidates are forced to address the issues that the third party candidate represents in order to win back those votes.

Ross Perot, who ran as an independent candidate in the 1992 presidential election, emphasized balancing the budget and reducing the deficit, which garnered him nearly 19 percent of the popular vote. One could argue that this impressive turnout showed race-winner Bill Clinton how important these issues were to the nation. “You don’t get innovation in a monopoly situation,” Janet Hopf chimed in during the post-debate audience discussion.

The Libertarian surrogate at the debate also gave another reason that voting for a third party candidates is a meaningful gesture.  Ron Moore mentioned that Gary Johnson is planning to run again in the 2016 presidential election and hopes to gain 5 percent of the popular vote in this year’s election. If political party  reaches the 5 percent threshold, that party will qualify for federal funding from the Federal Election Commission. The Commission passes out millions of dollars each year to major party campaigns and supports the Democratic and Republican National Conventions. The Commission is bound by law to level the playing field by donating to third party campaigns, but only if the party had ample support from the public in the previous election.

What might be a long shot campaign this year could become more of a reality in future elections. A Gallup poll released on September 12th asked the question, “Do Republican and Democratic parties do an adequate job representing the American people, or do they do such a poor job that a third major party is needed?” The poll’s result: 46 percent of Americans answered that they believe a third major party is needed to represent them. That percentage is actually down from 2008 and 2010 when 58 percent of Americans wanted a third party. (The drop may be due to the fact that the poll was taken right after the national conventions when major party solidarity is heightened.)

As the debate wound to a close and the audience milled around the cheese plates in the back of the room, voices rose as people chatted boisterously about health care plans, tax cuts and alternative energy sources. There was a buzz of energy. Audience members eventually drifted out of the room as the elderly staff of the community center put away the folding chairs and pushed the podium into a closet. As people walked out the door into the chilly darkness, the question on every mind was the same. Who is going to win? Whose vision of America’s future will guide the nation for the next four years?



Other Stories in Special Report: Election 2012

Minnesotans reject amendment to ban same-sex marriage

Kelsey Kudak November 7, 2012

Divided Electorate Votes to Give Obama More Time

Alex Jung November 7, 2012

How GenY Voted

Staff of The Beat Covering GenY November 6, 2012

North Carolina: Amendment One and the Black Vote

Alaia Howell November 6, 2012

Swing state students debate: absentee ballot or register at school?

Alyson Penn November 6, 2012

What’ll it Be, Mr. President?

Suzie Hodges November 6, 2012

Stand By Your Man

Cristina Alonso November 6, 2012

Colia Clark, Green Party candidate for Senate, Strives for Change

Robert Tutton November 6, 2012

Hydrofracking Becomes Issue in State Senate Race

Will Dietrich-Egensteiner November 6, 2012

A Warzone of Harassing Comments

Angela Flynn November 6, 2012

Harnessing the Youth Vote in 2012

Alena Hall November 6, 2012

From Assembly to Congress?

laura li November 6, 2012

A group of New Yorkers canvas in Philadelphia

Sarah Gray November 6, 2012

Black Voters Face Pressure from Voting Restrictions and from One Another

Melissa Bailey Diallo November 6, 2012

Chappaqua’s most famous residents: the Clintons

Laura Gurfein November 5, 2012

Chinese-American voters support Obama

Jia Guo November 5, 2012

West Africans views of the 2012 U.S. presidential election

Lauren Morton November 4, 2012

Key voter demographic: homeowners facing foreclosure

Eric Zerkel November 4, 2012

Carbon neutral cupcakes for Obama

Lori-Lee Emshey November 4, 2012

Saturdays for Obama

Laura Entis November 4, 2012

For Politico blogger Alex Burns covering the presidential campaign is science

Alissa Katz November 4, 2012

Brooklyn Tea Party President Runs for NY State Assembly

Renee Jacques November 4, 2012

Upcoming Election Provokes Anxiety for Trans Voters

Alex Jung November 4, 2012

Student’s choice: where one votes matters

Sarah Wentz November 4, 2012

A catch-22 for evangelical Latino voters

Corrie Mitchell November 4, 2012

Knitting and purling for Obama

Megan Soll November 4, 2012

Perspectives on New York’s new Congressional districts

Lila Selim November 2, 2012

American Catholics Divided over Politics of Contraception and Poverty

Peter DAmato November 2, 2012

Felons disenfranchised in New York and other states, despite the law

Emma Quail October 31, 2012

Technology challenges privacy during election campaigns

Anna Callaghan October 31, 2012

US foreign policy success in Burma overshadowed in election

Elizabeth Shim October 31, 2012

Local politicians court city’s Arab-American vote

Jackson Perry October 30, 2012

NYU students hustle to get the vote out

Sara Afzal October 29, 2012

The “Moho” Vote

Nicole Disser October 29, 2012

‘Stamp Stampede’ at Union Square

Morgan Ribera October 25, 2012

Home call centers foster camaraderie among volunteers

Ted Simmons October 18, 2012

Voices outside of the Hofstra Presidential Debate

Colleen Quigley October 16, 2012